330-867-5309
Quick Search
Join Sign In
Buy Sell Realtors & Company
  • Contact Us
    Careers
    Reviews
    Our Story
    Leadership Team
  • Offices

    Want more information on our offices? Select an office below.


  • Find A Realtor

    Already working with an Realtor or have one in mind? Search below.


Communities
Services Cash Advantage
Quick Home Search
All Regions Northeast Ohio Columbus & Central Ohio Cincinnati & Northern Kentucky
Real Estate Agent Amy Conley

Amy Conley

REALTOR®
Cell: (614) 595-4344
Contact Me Visit My Website
Save To Your Contacts
Make Preferred Realtor
Designations ?
  • ABR®Accredited Buyer's Representative®
  • ALCAccredited Land Consultant
  • ASPAccredited Staging Professional®
  • AHWDAt Home With Diversity
  • AHWD®At Home With Diversity®
  • CCIMCertified Commercial Investment Member
  • CDPECertified Distressed Property Expert®
  • CIDCertified Interior Decorator
  • CIPSCertified International Property Specialist
  • CIASCertified Investor Agent Specialist
  • CNECertified Negotiation Expert
  • CPM®Certified Property Manager®
  • CRBCertified Real Estate Brokerage Manager
  • CRENCertified Real Estate Negotiator
  • CRETSCertified Real Estate Team Specialist
  • CRSCertified Residential Specialist
  • CRE™Counselor of Real Estate™
  • GAAGeneral Accredited Appraiser
  • GRIGraduate, REALTOR® Institute
  • HHSHistoric House Specialist
  • MBAMaster of Business Administration
  • MRPMilitary Relocation Professional
  • GREENNAR's Green Designation
  • e-PRO®NAR's real estate technology certification
  • PMNPerformance Management Network
  • PSAProperty Strategy Advisor
  • RCEREALTOR® Association Certified Executive
  • RAAResidential Accredited Appraiser
  • RSPSResort & Second-Home Property Specialist
  • SRSSeller Representative Specialist
  • SRES®Seniors Real Estate Specialist®
  • SFR®Short Sales & Foreclosure Resource®
  • SIORSociety of Industrial and Office REALTORS®

CRS, NINJA CERTIFIED™

Specialties

Buyer's Agent, Condominiums, Listing Agent, Luxury Homes, New Construction, Relocation, Residential

Interests

Dog Lover, Family, Foodie, Skiing, Traveling

Biography

Cutler Real Estate asked Amy a few questions so you can get to know her better, and here are Amy's replies.

1. What is your professional/educational background?

Bachelors in Business

2. Why did you choose a career in real estate?

I followed in my mothers footsteps

3. What area do you live in currently and what do you like about where you live?

I just moved recently!  I now reside in Bexley -- an older walk-able community in Columbus. Previously I lived in German Village.

4. How do you spend your free time?

With family and friends and traveling if I can find the time

5. If you could only keep 3 possessions what would they be?

  1. My family
  2. Friends
  3. Dogs

6. In one word, how do you think your friends/family would describe you?

Strong Work Ethic, Generous and Kind

Full BioLess Bio
$3,375,000 Active 336 S Columbia Avenue
Columbus, OH 43209 6 beds 5 full/2 half baths 8,823 sqft mls 226009225 Buyer's Agent Compensation: 3% $875,000 Pending 436 S Parkview Avenue
Columbus, OH 43209 4 beds 2 full baths 2,754 sqft mls 226008979 Buyer's Agent Compensation: 3% $2,495,000 Active 1565 Berkshire Road
Columbus, OH 43221 5 beds 4 full/1 half baths 5,320 sqft mls 225039502
VIEW ALL LISTINGS
$474,900 Closed Listed at $479,900 517 Forest Street
Columbus, OH 43206 2 beds 2.0 baths 1,463 sqft mls 226004034 Buyer Represented $739,000 Closed Listed at $779,000 5515 Aryshire Court
Dublin, OH 43017 4 beds 3.1 baths 4,438 sqft mls 225032867 Buyer Represented $537,500 Closed Listed at $539,900 828 Bobcat Avenue
Columbus, OH 43212 2 beds 2.0 baths 1,402 sqft mls 226004182 Seller Represented
VIEW ALL SOLD LISTINGS
5/5 Based On 60 Ratings
ADD TESTIMONIAL
5/5 Based On 10 Ratings
5.0/5 Based On 10 Ratings
Apr 09, 2026
Working with Amy is 10/10. We cannot recommend working with Amy enough! Amy is extremely focused on customer service and is an excellent communicator with tons of experience. She's extremely knowledgeable of the Columbus area, especially in German Village and Bexley where we were focused. Working through all the paperwork and negotiations with Amy was a breeze and we could easily rely on her when we needed guidance.
--
Jan 01, 2026
Amy is an excellent agent. She is responsive, easy to work with and has years of experience in the industry. She has a great team as well. She helped us buy and sell our home with ease. In addition, she also has a lot of contacts that can help with home ownership. Overall we were very pleased working with Amy and her team and would recommend her 100% to anyone in the Columbus market.
--
Dec 11, 2025
Amy was beyond wonderful in helping us through a process we had not navigated for 39 years. She was extremely knowledgeable and professional and always a “step ahead”. In a very competitive seller’s market, Amy got us in, submitted an offer, and negotiated to its acceptance almost immediately. When the small surprises that are bound to come up presented themselves, Amy had options, suggestions, and forms (oh, the forms!) to solve any issue. Throughout what was undoubtedly a routine transaction for her, she made us feel like we were the most important part of her day. Her warm and friendly manner complement her capable professionalism.
--
Oct 17, 2025
Amy went above and beyond to help us in our time of need. We lost everything we owned in a house fire and she was extremely understanding of our short timeline and the fact that this was our first time buying a home. After reaching out to her on a weekend, we were already in talks with a lender and looking at homes by the end of the week. She was always was looking out for our best interests. While it's the only time I've worked with a realtor, I couldn't imaging there being a better one out there!
-- Aaron Beard
Jul 10, 2025
Amy and Becky did a great job on helping us secure a buyer and market our home. They were extremely responsive, professional, and timely. Amy has extensive knowledge and experience and it was evident. It was an enjoyable process from start to finish.
--
May 01, 2025
Amy perfectly helped us navigate a tight and unpredictable market to find the perfect house for us. She was knowledgeable and connected with what has happening and likely to come on the market.
-- Kristin R
Apr 25, 2025
Amy is a true professional - the best in the business. From go-to-market strategy to closing she guided us through the entire process. Not only is she respected by us but her deep bench of professional relationships brought clients in from 4 states to see our home. She and her team are amazing.
-- Stephen Lyons
Mar 10, 2025
I can't say enough good things about Amy. She knows the Bexley market (and others!) inside and out. She helped with both sale and purchase and was absolutely fantastic. She understood our family, saw our unique needs, and helped to make our move seamless. Highly recommend!
--
Mar 06, 2025
Amy was wonderful to work with. We relocated from out of state and she spent a lot of time with us showing us around Columbus so we could hone in on which suburb we wanted to live in. She has been patient with us throughout our year+ home building process. Amy is very knowledgeable about the greater Columbus area and is a wealth of expertise. She is well connected and has personal relationships that are invaluable. Amy guided us through the home building process and was instrumental in our meetings with the builder. She also has a great design eye and helped us make design selections. And to top it all off she is personable and fun! You can't go wrong with Amy and her team and anyone would be lucky to work with her.
--
Jan 13, 2025
Amy and her team deserve all the stars! As first time home buyers, my husband and I were unsure what to except and Amy walked us through the entire process. Everyone we’ve talked to has been shocked at how seamless and enjoyable our home buying process was with Amy! We could not recommend her enough!
--
VIEW ALL REVIEWS

Login to My Homefinder

Forgot Password

Register

Pixel